Alon Amit on Quora · 2015-11-13

Are there any numbers which don't fall into at least one of the categories of real numbers, imaginary numbers, or complex numbers?

Yes, here's one:

\displaystyle \frac{1-x}{1+x^2}.

"Wait!", I hear you cry. "That's not a number, It's a function!"

OK, let's think about that for a second.

Many years ago, when the human race was younger, the only "numbers" were 1, 2, 3, 4 and so on. In fact at one point it probably was "1, 2, 3, 4, plenty" and that's it. Much more recently, when you, dear reader, were younger, you probably held similar views.

Then we added the rational numbers, like \frac{4}{5}. "Wait!", someone must have said. "That's not a number, it's a ratio! It just expresses the fact that there are 5 ellsworths in 4 vrangels!". OK, we can call them "fractions" if you prefer, who cares? We learned to add and subtract and multiply them and at some point we decided to adorn them with the term "Numbers".

Does this change them? No. Does it change us? No. Does it change the world? No. It's just a word. We call these guys "rational numbers" but we can also call them "duplexes" and nothing changes.

Then we introduced negative numbers. And real numbers. And complex numbers. We still call them numbers, although they don't enumerate anything. How many apples is -3 apples? How long is a journey of \frac{1+i}{2} miles? [1]

We call them numbers because they are useful, because we can add and subtract and multiply and divide them, and that's it. We could have called them "Splorks" and reserve the word "Number" just to the natural numbers 1, 2, 3 and so on. Wouldn't matter a bit.

There are, actually, other objects in mathematics that are usually called "Numbers". I'll review some in a minute. The thing to understand though is that this is totally arbitrary. To go back to my first example, objects like \frac{1-x}{1+x^2} are usually called "rational functions" but we could just as well have called them "hypernumbers" or "functional numbers" or whatnot and then they would get included in lists of things that are numbers. It doesn't matter. It's not an interesting observation.

What is interesting is that there are lots and lots of wondrous objects in mathematics which, like the natural numbers, can be added and subtracted and multiplied, and they tell us really deep things about mathematical worlds and about the physical world.

As you can see, some of the things on this list are called "numbers" and some aren't, but there's no clear distinction between those that are and those that aren't so we shouldn't care about that.

Mathematics positively explodes with algebraic structures, and they are really, really beautiful. It's great to get to know them and learn how they interact and what they can teach us.

[1] Some commenters were annoyed at me for misunderstanding that a journey of \frac{1+i}{2} miles has length \sqrt{2}/2. Nope, that’s a journey from 0 to the point \frac{1+i}{2}, which isn’t what I said. A journey of length \sqrt{2}/2 has length \sqrt{2}/2. A journey of “length” \frac{1+i}{2} doesn’t exist because non-real numbers aren’t measuring the length of anything.

Originally posted on Quora: https://qr.ae/pFmzO8